
Games like Forgive Me Father
Loved Forgive Me Father by Byte Barrel? Here are 24 games that genuinely play like it — ranked by shared genres, mechanics and themes, not just labels.

Forgive Me Father2021MC 74
Byte Barrel · ~8h to beat
A dark retro horror FPS set in a comic book style world inspired by the novels of H.P. Lovecraft. As the only one with full senses, you begin a journey in search for answers and relief. How long can you last?
24 games similar to Forgive Me Father

84
5.0
Resident Evil Village
38% similarDark FantasyReligionHorror

83
5.2
Alan Wake
35% similarCosmic HorrorHorrorExploration

89
5.0
Alan Wake II
35% similarCosmic HorrorMultiple ProtagonistsDetective

88
5.0
Dusk
33% similarCosmic Horror

82
5.0
My Friendly Neighborhood
31% similarCartoonyHorror

78
5.0
The Sinking City 2
30% similarCosmic HorrorDetectiveHorror

83
5.0
Forgive Me Father 2
30% similarHorror

77
5.0
Lovecraft's Untold Stories
29% similarCosmic HorrorExploration

81
5.0
Far Cry 5
29% similarReligionExploration

5.0
Holy Shoot
28% similarCartoony

67
5.0
The Mound: Omen of Cthulhu
28% similarCosmic HorrorExploration

61
5.0
I Hate this Place
28% similarCartoonyHorrorExploration

72
5.0
Wizard With a Gun
28% similarCartoonyExploration

80
5.0
Remnant II
27% similarDark FantasyHorrorExploration

86
5.0
Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne
27% similarComic BookMultiple ProtagonistsDetective

83
5.0
Resident Evil 5
27% similarCosmic HorrorMultiple Protagonists

5.0
Witchfire
27% similarDark Fantasy

94
5.4
BioShock Infinite
26% similarReligionMultiple ProtagonistsHorror

75
5.0
The Evil Within
26% similarReligionDetectiveHorror

74
5.0
Warhammer 40,000: Darktide
26% similarDark FantasyHorror

88
5.0
Kill Knight
26% similarCosmic HorrorDark Fantasy

5.0
Lovecraft Game
26% similarCosmic Horror

83
5.0
Doom: The Dark Ages
26% similarDetective

79
5.0
Wolfenstein: The New Order
25% similarReligion