Games like Pony Island
Loved Pony Island by Daniel Mullins Games? Here are 24 games that genuinely play like it — ranked by shared genres, mechanics and themes, not just labels.
Pony Island2016MC 86
Daniel Mullins Games · ~3h to beat
Pony Island is a suspense puzzle game in disguise. You are in limbo, trapped in a malevolent and malfunctioning arcade machine devised by the devil himself. It is not a game about ponies.
24 games similar to Pony Island
85
5.0
Manifold Garden
30% similarSurrealPuzzleExploration
71
5.0
Bendy and the Ink Machine
28% similarDemonsPuzzleExploration
73
5.0
The Mortuary Assistant
28% similarDemonsSurrealExploration
80
5.0
Transpose
28% similarSurrealPuzzleExploration
87
5.0
The Witness
27% similarSurrealIslandPuzzle
76
5.0
Pikuniku
26% similarSurrealPuzzleExploration
86
5.0
Her Story
26% similarSurreal
83
5.0
Quern - Undying Thoughts
26% similarSurrealIslandPuzzle
73
5.0
while True: learn()
25% similarPuzzle
75
5.0
Madison
25% similarDemonsPuzzleExploration
90
5.0
Opus Magnum
24% similarSimulationPuzzle
73
5.0
Poly Bridge
23% similarPuzzle
83
5.0
Riven: The Sequel to Myst
23% similarSurrealPuzzleExploration
96
5.0
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
23% similarIsland
5.0
Paw Patrol: On a Roll!
23% similarShoot 'Em Up
5.0
Exapunks
23% similarPuzzle
84
5.0
Viewfinder
22% similarSurrealPuzzle
5.0
The Baby In Yellow
22% similarSurrealPuzzle
90
5.0
Stephen's Sausage Roll
22% similarPuzzle
5.0
The Exit 8
22% similarSurrealExploration
72
5.0
Assassin's Creed Unity
22% similarRunner
85
5.0
Outer Wilds
22% similarExploration
5.0
Arctic Eggs
22% similarSurreal
77
5.0
7 Billion Humans
22% similarPuzzle