
Games like Mafia: The Old Country
Loved Mafia: The Old Country by Hangar 13? Here are 24 games that genuinely play like it — ranked by shared genres, mechanics and themes, not just labels.

Mafia: The Old Country2025MC 73
Hangar 13 · ~13h to beat
Mafia: The Old Country is an action-adventure game part of the Mafia series. It is a prequel to the first Mafia game. The game lets players descend into Sicily's criminal underworld during the 1900s.
24 games similar to Mafia: The Old Country

86
5.0
Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne
36% similarCrimeThird-PersonDetective

78
5.0
The Sinking City 2
36% similarHistoricalThird-PersonDetective

87
5.0
Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus
36% similarHistorical

70
5.1
Payday: The Heist
34% similarCrime

66
5.0
Payday 3
33% similarCrime

88
5.5
Battlefield 1
33% similarHistorical

85
5.0
Pragmata
31% similarThird-PersonDetectiveSurvival

93
5.0
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End
31% similarThird-Person

96
4.9
Half-Life 2
31% similarHistorical

69
5.0
Wolfenstein: Youngblood
30% similarHistorical

89
5.2
Borderlands 2
30% similarCrime

78
5.0
Remnant: From the Ashes
30% similarHistoricalThird-PersonSurvival

70
5.0
Atomic Heart
30% similarHistorical

82
5.0
Watch Dogs 2
30% similarCrimeThird-Person

89
5.0
Death Stranding 2: On the Beach
29% similarThird-PersonSurvivalStory Rich

86
5.0
Rise of the Tomb Raider
29% similarThird-PersonSurvival

73
5.0
Atomic Heart II
28% similarHistorical

84
5.0
Fallout: New Vegas
28% similarHistoricalCrimeThird-Person

87
5.2
Uncharted: Legacy of Thieves Collection
28% similarThird-PersonStory Rich

83
5.0
Doom: The Dark Ages
27% similarDetective

93
5.0
Resident Evil 4
27% similarCrimeThird-Person

73
5.0
Strange Brigade
27% similarHistoricalDetective

94
5.4
BioShock Infinite
27% similarHistoricalStory Rich

77
5.0
Quantum Break
27% similarThird-PersonSurvivalStory Rich